2003 E2 nightclub stampede
Dwain Kyles
b) several building code violations
b) 2 years' probation
The E2 nightclub stampede occurred on February 17, 2003, at the E2 nightclub above the Epitome restaurant at 2347 South Michigan Avenue in the South Loop neighborhood of Chicago, Illinois, in which 21 people died and more than 50 were injured when panic ensued from the use of pepper spray by a security guard to break up a fight. The club's owners were convicted of criminal contempt for their persistent failure to keep the facility up to code, and sentenced to two years probation.
Incident
The stampede was triggered by club security using pepper spray to break up a fight. Several patrons close to the commotion experienced vomiting or fainting from the spray's noxious fumes and others, believing the club to have been hit with poison gas in a terrorist attack, rushed towards the exit.[1] The exit was the steep front stairwell leading to the main entrance on the ground floor, the narrow doors of which opened inward – a fire code violation. Additionally, while the doors were normally kept open during business hours, they had been closed after the fight participants were ejected. Although at least one emergency exit was opened by a security guard, there were disputed reports of another chained shut. People climbing the stairs were knocked down and pinned by the crowd. As security attempted to pull them to safety, the heap of bodies reached six feet in height as more than 1,500 people fled the perceived threat. While trying to free trapped patrons, E2 guard Ira Navarro heard other clubbers atop the stairs laughing at the fracas, unaware of the fatalities.[2]
Victims
Twenty-one patrons – twelve women and nine men, between the ages of 19 and 43 – died from compressional asphyxiation and more than 50 others were injured.[3]
Legal
A number of controversies arose from the case. A city-issued court order showed that the owners, Dwain Kyles and Calvin Hollins, were guilty of eleven building code violations, including overcrowding and faulty exit lighting.[1][4] Police were called to the location 80 times during the two years prior to the stampede.[4] Kyles and Hollins had been ordered to shut down the second-floor club in 2002. Their attorneys claimed that the court order related only to a raised VIP section of the club, not the entire second floor of the building.[5] City inspectors then believed the facility's only business thereafter came from the ground floor Epitome Chicago restaurant, which the club attorneys said was false as police officers (both on and off duty) regularly handled the persistently large crowds, and club advertisements were common on radio and the Internet.[5]
During the January 2007 trial, the prosecution claimed the club's security staff were not properly trained. Security guard Samuel Bone testified to using pepper spray to disband a group of fifteen brawling clubbers. He said he was indeed trained in the proper use of pepper spray by the nonprofit Illinois Police Reserve Patrol.[6] On November 25, 2009, Kyles and Hollins were acquitted of involuntary manslaughter charges, but were found guilty of indirect criminal contempt for violating the court order to close the entire second floor of the club and were sentenced to two years probation.[7]
E2 and Epitome both permanently closed after the incident.[8] On November 16, 2011, the ruling was overturned when a judge ruled that the court order to close the second floor was ambiguous.[9] On April 4, 2013, the Illinois Supreme Court unanimously overturned the 2011 ruling and upheld the 2009 conviction of criminal contempt, calling the court order "certain, clear and concise."[10]
See also
- The Station nightclub fire, fatal fire in Rhode Island only three days after.
References
- ^ a b Judge blocks charges against E2 owners – CNN.com, 2/19/2003
- ^ Some laughed in E2 stampede: Patrons did not know they were shoving others to their deaths – Chicago Sun-Times, 1/19/07; reprinted on highbeam.com
- ^ All E2 victims were crushed – Chicago Tribune, 1/26/2007
- ^ a b In Chicago, Jesse on the Spot Archived 2011-12-20 at the Wayback Machine – Time, 2/24/03
- ^ a b Chicago overwhelmed by nightclub deaths – CNN.com, 2/25/03
- ^ Bouncer describes E2 crowd: Guard says he used pepper spray in fight – Chicago Tribune, 1/23/07; reprinted on highbeam.com
- ^ E2 Owners Get 2 Years In Prison Archived 2009-11-27 at the Wayback Machine – WBBM, 11/25/09
- ^ E2 Stampede Remembered Six Years Later – NBC Chicago, 2/2009
- ^ "E2 owners say they were scapegoats for 'botched rescue effort'". Chicago Tribune. Retrieved 28 January 2016.
- ^ "Supreme Court: E2 conviction stands: Owners of club where 21 died again facing jail". Chicago Tribune. April 5, 2013.
External links
- Tribune coverage from the Chicago Tribune
- v
- t
- e
- 1807 Newgate Prison
- 1823 Valletta
- 1876 Brooklyn Theatre
- 1883 Victoria Hall
- 1896 Khodynka
- 1902 Shiloh Baptist Church
- 1903 Iroquois Theatre
- 1908 Barnsley Hall
- 1913 Italian Hall
- 1927 Laurier Palace
- 1943 Bethnal Green
- 1946 Burnden Park
- 1954 Kumbh Mela
- 1964 Estadio Nacional
- 1965 El Progreso Bullring
- 1967 Atatürk Stadium
- 1971 Ibrox
- 1974 Zamalek
- 1977 Xinjiang 61st Regiment Farm
- 1979 The Who concert
- 1981 Karaiskakis Stadium
- 1982 Luzhniki
- 1985 Heysel Stadium
- 1987 Shanghai Lujiazui
- 1988 Dasharath Stadium
- 1989 Tbilisi
- 1989 Hillsborough
- 1990 Mecca
- 1991 Oppenheimer Stadium
- 1992 Mahamaham
- 1992 Bastia
- 1993 Lan Kwai Fong
- 1994 Mecca
- 1994 Gowari
- 1996 Haridwar and Ujjain
- 1997 Uphaar Cinema
- 1998 Mecca
- 1999 Sabarimala
- 1999 Nyamiha (Minsk)
- 2000 Throb nightclub disaster
- 2001 Mecca
- 2001 Ellis Park Stadium
- 2001 Accra Sports Stadium
- 2001 Akashi pedestrian bridge
- 2003 E2 nightclub
- 2003 The Station nightclub
- 2004 Mecca
- 2004 Miyun
- 2005 Mandher Devi temple
- 2005 Al-Aaimmah bridge
- 2005 Chennai (November)
- 2005 Chennai (December)
- 2006 Mecca
- 2006 PhilSports Stadium
- 2008 Bandung
- 2008 Naina Devi temple
- 2008 Jodhpur
- 2009 Houphouët-Boigny
- 2009 Mawazine
- 2010 Kor Royal Cup
- 2010 Pratapgarh
- 2010 Love Parade
- 2010 Phnom Penh
- 2011 Sabarimala
- 2012 Port Said Stadium
- 2012 Satsanga Deoghar
- 2013 Houphouët-Boigny
- 2013 Kiss nightclub
- 2013 Kumbh Mela
- 2013 Madhya Pradesh
- 2014 Mumbai
- 2014 Stade Tata Raphaël
- 2014 Patna
- 2014 Multan
- 2014 Kwekwe
- 2014 Shanghai Bund
- 2015 30 June Stadium
- 2015 Haiti
- 2015 Mina
- 2015 Colectiv nightclub
- 2017 Turin
- 2017 Mumbai
- 2018 Caracas
- 2018 Corinaldo
- 2019 Antananarivo
- 2019 Karbala
- 2019 Caracas
- 2020 Kerman
- 2020 Maligawatta
- 2020 Los Olivos
- 2021 Meron
- 2021 Astroworld Festival
- 2022 Vaishno Devi Temple
- 2022 Yaoundé
- 2022 Port Harcourt
- 2022 GBLA Stadium
- 2022 Giza
- 2022 Kanjuruhan Stadium
- 2022 Seoul
- 2023 Arabian Gulf Cup
- 2023 Pakistan
- 2023 Sanaa
- 2023 San Salvador
- 2023 Brazzaville